FDA proposes new end-to-end traceability rule

The FDA has proposed a new rule that lays the foundation for the end-to-end food traceability across the food industry that it will be working toward over the next decade as part of the New Era of Smarter Food Safety initiative.

The FDA defines traceability as “the ability to track a food at every step of the supply chain.” While limited to certain foods, this proposed rule would create a first-of-its-kind standardized approach to traceability recordkeeping, paving the way for industry to adopt and leverage more digital, tech-enabled traceability systems both in the near term and the future.

The FDA are also released a draft Food Traceability List that identifies foods to which the additional recordkeeping requirements would apply.

A bridge to the New Era of Smarter Food Safety

Congress recognized the need for greater traceability in the FDA Food Safety Modernization Act (FSMA). FSMA section 204, Enhancing Tracking and Tracing of Food and Recordkeeping, instructs the FDA to develop additional recordkeeping requirements for certain foods to help establish clear tracing of a food product’s source when needed to address food safety risks. This proposed rule, when finalized, would implement this key component of the landmark food safety law. We recognize that to fully realize the public health benefits envisioned by FSMA, we need to continue to improve our ability to rapidly and accurately identify foods that may be causing illness, and this rulemaking is part of that.

When FDA Commissioner Stephen Hahn and Deputy Commissioner for Food Policy and Response Frank Yiannas announced the New Era of Smarter Food Safety Blueprint in July, this proposed rule was presented as the first step in the FDA’s work to advance traceability. The agency’s goal is to help protect consumers by more quickly identifying the source of contaminated products, limiting the scope of recalls, and reducing the risk of illness or death. Advancing traceability will also greatly facilitate timelier root-cause investigations to learn more about how contamination occurs in order to prevent future outbreaks.

A game changer for prevention

Consumers don’t normally think of food traceability as being a means of preventing foodborne illness, but like many of the improvements in food safety over the years, such as whole genome sequencing, what the FDA proposed has a direct impact on preventing foodborne illness.

More comprehensive traceability through access to records of key data elements associated with critical tracking events in food production and distribution has the potential to help us pinpoint the exact sources of foods involved in outbreaks. Not only does this help us to remove potentially unsafe products from the market more quickly, preventing additional illness or death, but it also helps us to conduct root cause investigations to figure out what went wrong leading to the outbreak. Without knowing the source of a contaminated food is extremely hard, if not impossible, for us to fully diagnose the problem and work with industry to develop and implement strategies to prevent similar issues in the future. Recent outbreaks of foodborne illness tied to fresh produce like leafy greens and papayas, among others, highlight the importance of this work.

Harmonizing approaches

Today’s food system has changed as the way our society operates changes, creating a complex and globally connected landscape that changes how food moves through supply chains.

When the FDA looked at the current state of traceability across the food supply, it found that even though some food producers, manufacturers and retailers have adopted modern, effective traceability systems, rarely are these systems compatible with each other. And still, many other food companies have not adopted traceability systems at all. A harmonized system of traceability from farm to fork that is universally understood and utilized is lacking.

This means that during an outbreak investigation, the industry’s ability to rapidly track and trace specific food products through the supply chain is often impeded by a lack of data. The result can be millions of dollars in avoidable product loss by necessitating overly broad recalls and consumer advisories, a loss of consumer trust, and prolonged outbreaks of consumer illnesses and deaths.

The FDA conducted extensive research in developing this proposed rule and chose an approach that would standardize the data elements and information companies must establish and maintain, along with information they must send to the next entity in the supply chain. The agency took into consideration the existing standards that some firms and industry groups have already adopted, and when possible, it have strived to make the proposed requirements compatible with those standards.

Benefits of better traceability

According to Yiannas’ statement, the approach laid out in the proposed rule would allow the FDA to better establish linkages throughout the supply chain during a foodborne illness outbreak investigation and more quickly identify potential sources of contamination and prevent additional illness and death.

The availability of the traceability records that are set out in the proposed rule would also help limit the scope of recalls and in some instances, allow the FDA to better target consumer advice, avoiding blanket alerts on whole commodity sectors. For instance, in some past leafy green outbreaks, the FDA has had to call for all romaine lettuce to be removed from the marketplace when the available supply chain information could not pinpoint a specific entity that produced the lettuce linked to the illnesses. With this proposed rule, the FDA hopes to avoid situations like this in the future.

Yiannas said: “I am excited to continue collaborating with stakeholders as we work to finalize this rule, and further enhance traceability. We are encouraging you to be involved in this process by commenting on the proposed rule. We look forward to announcing public meetings to discuss this proposed rule with everyone interested in food safety and value input from all stakeholders during the comment period.

“Working together, we will advance food traceability and usher in a New Era of Smarter Food Safety that benefits producers and consumers.”

LGMA statement

The California Leafy Greens Marketing Agreement (LGMA) issued the following statement Sept. 21 in response to the new FDA proposed traceability rule.

“The U.S. Food and Drug Administration announced today they are adding traceability requirements to the Food Safety Modernization Act for certain foods including leafy greens. We want to assure our customers and consumers that members of the Leafy Greens Marketing Agreement are already required to have traceback systems in place. This has been part of the LGMA requirements since the organization was formed in 2007. In a recent survey of our membership, the LGMA found the systems in place by California leafy green farmers allow them to quickly trace product back to the field where it was grown and forward to the first customer who receives it.

It appears the members of the LGMA in California and Arizona are already in compliance with new requirements announced today.  As with any other aspect of our program, the LGMA is committed to making any necessary improvements to protect consumers.

For more information, see the press release issued last week by the LGMA.”